Thursday, 16 August 2012

Helplessness, Heartbreak and yet Hope

Before I came to medical school, I always wanted to be a paediatrician. But my father questioned my ability to really cope with the difficulties of dealing with sick children every day of my life. Seeing reason in his logic, I turned my thoughts away from it and have been a self-confessed neuro/neurosurgery/surgery junkie ever since. However, fourth year paediatrics gave me a taste and my thoughts turned once again to the idea of pursuing a career in paeds.

To me, paeds is one of those all or nothing specialties, sort of like OBGYN, where, when things are going well, the rewards are enormous, but when things go badly, they go horrendously. I suppose this dichotomy of good and bad is less pronounced in countries like ours, but in a place like Mwanza, it feels as though there are only highs and lows.

Our final week at Sekou Toure proved to be one of the most difficult. We came to have a sense of being due a ‘bad day’ when several days would go by without incident. So when we arrived on Monday morning to find a mother on her knees in floods of tears outside the ward, we took it to be a bad sign. As usual, there were a couple of kids on beds in the treatment room with their parents and it was fairly quiet, given some days we arrive to children fitting or neonates in severe respiratory distress. As we sat down, Emily came on the ward, a little less cheery than usual, saying it had been a busy night and that the kid on the bed nearest us had come in with either intoxication from traditional herbs or severe malaria, from delaying medical treatment and heading for herbs first.

Chris and I were fairly accustomed by this point to Emily saying things like “They were very toxic! Very sick!” and then her being very pleased with their recovery. But with this case, I felt something was strange, as on closer inspection, I noticed the kanga (traditional cloth with special messages used by almost all mothers on the ward as everything from clothing to bath towel) on the child was covering his face…and that the kanga was extraordinarily still. So, I asked Emily, what the child’s status was now, to which she said “That kid? That one is dead”. His father sat in tears next to him, blindly fiddling with his phone, and the image of the crying mother outside the ward suddenly made sense. A passing senior doctor commanded that we touch the child, who was still warm, and demanded to know why we hadn’t done something. After explaining our student status, he wandered off. We started ward round, and I had to fight to keep it together, as I watched the father and mother, silhouetted in the bright equatorial sunshine flooding through the entrance of the ward as they carried out the body of their 6 year old son.

The next day, we arrived and with no wrecked mother outside, I counted it as a better day already. Again, the treatment room was quiet, with just one nurse attending to a tiny baby and the baby’s mother standing there quietly. We went through our usual greetings with the nurse, which take a considerable amount of time in East Africa, with almost 10 different ways to say ‘hello’, after which she said ‘Doctor, please can I borrow a stethoscope? I want to confirm death in this baby’. Disbelieving my ears, given her unhurried demeanour, I went over, brushing my hand against an ice cold hand, to hear a painfully slow bradycardia (slowed heart beat) heaving inside a tiny chest. We wanted to start CPR, and asked the nurse whether there was anyone to help to which she replied blankly ‘there are no doctors, only you’. The nurse went for an ambu bag for what seemed to be a long time, time which the baby had little to lose. I dashed into the corridor intending to help her find the bag, to find her sauntering casually along, ambu bag in hand. When she did eventually put the bag on the baby’s face (the wrong way round), she seemed to have, firstly, a poor understanding of how to use the bag, and secondly, a complete lack of interest in what we were doing. I pushed down on the chest with two fingers as I have only ever seen done in demonstrations or on YouTube (as APLS is not part of the undergraduate medical training). And we kept going, for what seemed like an eternity, but was most likely only a couple of minutes, when Dr Bee passed by the window. To his credit, he did come onto the ward, and though again hands-off (‘I don’t want to put on gloves’), he tried to talk us through what to do. After a time, he told us to stop because it was futile and there was no longer any heart beat. He left the ward immediately after that, muttering something about paperwork. The mother, who I had largely forgotten through all of this, was looking confused, but calm, until the nurse simply said ‘pole mama’. At which point, she suddenly realised what had happened and began to cry, a terrible cry that will haunt me forever. I sat with her saying nothing, knowing that no Swahili or English words would ever be enough.   I wanted more than anything in that moment for my hand on her hand to convey a remorse that transcended our different races, cultures, languages and situations. She too had to carry the body of her child out of the ward herself.

On both these days, there was such a marked difference to the treatment of the whole situation to that of in the UK. The lack of urgency, protocol and personnel were all difficult to reconcile with our perception of ‘medicine’ and the lack of silence around the parents, the perfunctory ‘pole’ (sorry), the parents’ having to handle the bodies themselves jarred with my ideas of emotional sensitivity.

But, to dwell too long on these losses in Mwanza is a luxury they can ill afford, with a ward of 35 patients 
and just Emily, Chris and I to review them, some in critical conditions themselves. And to wallow in the helplessness is to miss the hope that lies in the children that we have managed to help, giggling and playing with keyrings/bottles/cardboard with such joy you’d think they were the latest electronic gaming device or the shy hug from a four year old girl that could have died the day before.

If I could somehow manage to always remember that there is hope for others even when there is none for some, perhaps paediatrics isn’t out of the question after all.


Monday, 13 August 2012

Beasts and Bargaining

If there’s one thing I’ve learnt out here, it’s that ‘Africa Time’ is not my friend. I don’t do well with walking at a snail’s pace, I don’t do well with inefficiency of any kind in clinic or on the ward and I especially don’t do well when the Safari Company we’ve prepaid to pick us up early arrives 2 hours late.

But arrive they did and Chris and I were packed off with a box of food by Mama Lefi and we clambered eagerly into the 9-seater land rover that looked like it could withstand a charge from a rhino…

That was until we hit Magu, a town just an hour into our journey when we had to visit a local garage to fix ‘a small problem’. Thinking it wouldn’t be long (considering our driver’s gushings of ‘only 15 minutes!’) we went to stretch our legs. When our cook for the weekend brought us our packed lunches, however, we began to suspect our old frenemy Africa Time might be making an unwelcome appearance. 3 hours (and 2 angry phone calls to the company) later, we were on our way again.

Arriving in Bunda at 15:00 to pick up the rest of our group, we were met by 3 less than chirpy girls who had been ready since 10:30 for our arrival. But, we were all quick to put aside our quibbles as soon as we could open the roof! Our joy lasted all of 15 seconds, which is how long it took for the engine to stall and we had to be nudged into the park by a passing land rover… not exactly the roaring start we had hoped for for our safari!

The Serengeti lives up to its Maasai meaning of ‘endless plains’ with pale yellow grassland as high as a man’s thigh as far as the eye can see, save for the occasional towering Acacia tree. Animals are everywhere…the trick is spotting them. But we were lucky, spotting Twiga (giraffes) without fail everyday, despite their non-territorial nature) and some amazing secluded moments with a family of elephants. Although Edward, our experienced driver, had to quieten the squeals of delight for fear of angering them. Our, surprisingly blood-thirsty companions, ironically the vegetarian baying the loudest, got their wish for death as we watched a warthog (not pumba!!) get taken down to hyena town. Speaking of hyenas, we also had the pleasure of watching one feed on…another hyena. A hunting pack of lions were also spotted, although they were surprisingly poor, completely unsubtlely walking in the road, which gave us excellent photo opportunities, but also allowed all the Thompson gazelle in the area to prance to freedom. An idiotic freedom, marked by their suicidal tendencies towards land rovers…

At both sunrise on our early morning game drives and at sunset before we reached a new campsite, there were random, lusty bursts of ‘The Circle of Life’, much to the chargrin of all the men in the car…so Chris. Camping itself was an experience, with none of the campsites with closed boundaries (my parents will be thrilled to hear) and so zebras, hyenas and even an elephant were often spotted wandering onto the sites. IN between avoiding animal wanderings, we had a chance to look up and see the clearest night sky, clear enough even to see the ghostly white smear of the Milky Way and to appreciate a true moon rising.

At the Naabi Hill Gate between the Serengeti and the Ngorongoro Conservation Area (NCA), we had our first taste of corruption as our paperwork, despite being OK at the Serengeti gate, was not Ok here. The officials at the gate demanded payment of $350 there and then. After some frantic calls to the comapany, who informed us that this was not uncommon here and that the officials did this for ‘their own benefit’, we were told that we should pay by card to be reimbursed later. Sadly, the officials had other ideas, stating ‘oh no, we don’t take Visa/Mastercard…Don’t you have cash?’. Well, we thought it was over, no more safari, but then an Oscar-worthy burst of fierce hot tears emitted from the aforementioned Vegetarian.

It never ceases to amaze me how there are a few quintessential things that will make most men baulk and amongst talk of periods and tampons, a crying girl strikes fear into the heart of even the most hardened tourist hunter. Miraculously, our paperwork was suddenly fine again and we were off.

It was at this point that I decided to use the highly effective, yet rarely seen Teoh-Liow combo negotiation smack-down. With all the firmness of my father I rang the company and let them know the dissatisfaction we felt with the company and that we hope for -no – demanded compensation. And with all the sweetness of my mother, i let them know how long we poor students had saved for safari and how I wished her and her family a nicer weekend than we were having. Sure enough, no less than an hour later the company rang back with an offer from the director himself of a full extra day and night of safari for free. Even as the group congratulated me, I heard my father’s voice in my head (as I so often have on this trip) saying I should have asked for more…

The Ngorongoro Crater is one of the most stunning places on earth. A UNESCO world heritage site, the hordes of wildebeast and zebra frolick together as brothers on a backdrop of towering blue-grey mountains topped with rolling clouds that fold over like gentle waves. Covering 8300 squared km, the NCA has many diverse habitats and it was here that we completed the Big Five (lion, elephant, buffalo, leopard and rhino) as we spotted the elusive Black Rhino. Lions stalk out their prey in serengeti-like grass whilst colobus monkeys swing from jungle trees and flamingos dip their long legs in a shimmer ice blue lake.

Leaving the Serengeti and all its hundreds of wazungu (Europeans) and wachina (no prizes for guessing what that is), to the dusty hot chaos of the Mwanza-Musoma highway was a shock. It brought us back to reality as our driver purchased a live chicken for his dinner and it squawked all the way home at our feet. Although he probably could have got it cheaper, or even one for free with the Teoh-Liow haggle, I thought it best not to intervene…

Friday, 10 August 2012

Medicine in Mwanza: The 3Ms

When I think about myself as an F1 on the wards, I envisage learning safe in the knowledge that there will more often than not be senior help whenever I require it. And even in the worst case, I envisage it being acute meningitis or respiratory distress on a lonely on call, both of which have clear trust guidelines for treating. Which makes what the intern doctor, let's call her Emily, Sekou Toure's equivalent of an F1 does everyday.

Emily graduated as an MD less than a year ago. She is a smiling, calm woman, who also happens to be a nun who is often dressed in a full habit beneath her white coat. She is on call, not 1 in 7, not 1 in 2 but everyday, all day, because her senior has been gone for going on a month. So, she runs ward round, on her own, making all clinical decisions based on no obs and little experience. She also runs outpatient clinic, which doubles as Paediatric A&E on her own.

Emily is occasionally joined by a general physician, let's call him Dr. Bee. Dr. Bee is probably the equivalent of a consultant locum doctor, offering help where needed, but seeming to have no fixed ward. Dr Bee is a bumbling fellow, who has a habit of talking over his left shoulder and expecting the mother/nurse/frantic english medical student to hear over the screaming children in the ward, and penmanship comparable to a slug who has been dipped in ink rolling sadly across a page.

Unfortunately for Emily, Dr Bee takes the 'hands off' teaching approach to a whole other level, often disappearing in the middle of ward round or after seeing on epatient in out patients. On one particularly memorable occasion, Emily and Chris had clerked a patient with Kerosene poisoning (on a particularly busy and harrowing day), when Dr. Bee arrived on the scene. Emily handed him the chart for him to review the patient, at which point he actively recoiled and told her to take care of it. It was then up to Emily to insist and reassure him that she and Chris had done all the legwork and all that was needed was a check of her management plan. I can't imagine being so unsupported.

As we joined Emily for ward round on our first day, it became clear that the majority of cases on the ward
can be attributed to one of the 3 Ms: Malaria, Malnourishment and (a lack of) Money. Since there are no obs, or investigations/diagnostic tests beyond a full blood count (which is rarely ordered), every child is treated for Malaria, irrespective of their presenting complaint, be it diarrhoea or headache. One morning we found Emily rather preoccupied and found a boy in the treatement room who had been seizing for over an hour. He had had no response to diazepam (a first-line anti convulsant) and there was no phenobarbitone in the hospital which is what Emily wanted. We watched, horrified, as the mother held him down as he seized, another screaming child on her back as the nurse administered IV antibiotics and glucose. Still seizing, Emily said we may as well start rounds, as there was nothing more we could do. She later told us, after the boy had recovered due to the glucose we gave, that she had fully expected that boy to die. His hypoglycaemic fits were probably due to severe malaria.

Mothers have a generally poor understanding of childcare, with many of them not breastfeeding adequately due to reasons such as 'i have a sore leg' or ' the child is sick'. One child was so emaciated his head had the same size as the rest of his body combined, and weighed just 3.5kg at 5 months of age (a healthy birth weight for you non-medics). The comment of 'child is severely malnourished' makes an appearance as a chance finding on examination far too often.

The final M, lack of money, is evident in all the patients who come in, whether it be not enough money to feed the eighth child of the family or to buy medications to treat them. A particularly poignant case was a child Chris and I saw in clinic who had a fairly classic case of asthma with an infection. Her lungs were very wheezy throughout and after prescribing bronchodilators, steroids and oxygen and admitting her, we thought no more of her. The next day on WR, we found her chest to be nowhere near improved. For a start, the only oxygen in the ward is a giant tank that gives a measly 2L through nasal cannulae. Still, with the treatment we had described she still should have had some improvement. Puzzled, we turned to her treatment page to find only the words 'hana dawa' written over and over where her doses of medication should have been recorded. Simply, she did not have the money for the medications and so no medication was given. She didn't even have just a simple salbutamol inhaler that Chris has nestled in his suitcase at home.

Another obstacle that presents which relates to the last M is that of traditional medicine. As it is often cheaper, parents often opt for that first, as was the case of a young girl who had 2nd degree burns all over 20% of her tiny body. She fell into boiling porridge 3 days previously and her mother's treatment? Honey and herbs as per the local witch doctor's advice. The girl must have been in excrutiating pain, howling with the smallest movement as we examined her.

Seeing the 3Ms of Sekou Toure (that are no doubt symptomatic of a much wider Tanzanian and perhaps even African problem), it's hard to not to think that Paediatrics in the UK suffers a little from the 4Ms: Mothers Making Mountains out of Molehills...

Sunday, 5 August 2012

Starting at Sekou Toure

Considering I'm purportedly here for a medical elective, followers of this blog might be forgiven for thinking I'm just on holiday! Sekou Toure Regional Hospital is a relatively large governmental hospital (the 2nd largest in Mwanza). On entering the building, the lack of fluorescent lighting leaves the eyes of the patients in the crammed waiting room the only source of brightness as our eyes are still smarting from the harsh equatorial sunshine.

Despite first being led onto the O and G ward where women in various stages of labour were milling about in a dank, ammonia sodden dim room, occasionally punctuated by flashes of a white calico darting in and out of the ward, we quickly made a get-away to the Paediatric ward. A welcome contrast to the maternity ward, the syunlight streamed into the bay of beds, onto the children. There are 7 bays of 6 beds per room, plus one 'admissions/triage/treatment/overflow room'. ON first glance, one could be forgiven for thinking it was a normal hospital ward. But as I looked, I noticed subtle but crucial differences from a privileged NHS trust hospital.

There are no observation machines, so instead of glancing down at a handy graphical representation of temperature, respiratory rate, heart rate, O2 saturation and BP religiously completed by HCAs, we have nothing at all. Well, not nothing, we have 'clinical impressions' in the 30 seconds we can spend with each patient in ward round. There are no curtains next to the beds, mothers share a bedside table between two, doors long gone from some, others crawling with cockroaches when the doors open.

The one thermometer that gives a half decent reading is often not available as the doctor it belongs to is not permanently on the ward. So, the main way to assess a malaria patient's raging fever? The back of a hand. Patients have to supply their own needles, syringes and medications-forget about a fully stocked supply room and multiple tries to get a cannula in.

Instead of alcohol gel hanging off the end of each bed, there's the second (healthy) child of the mother who doesn't have anyone or anywhere to leave her. Sinks in each bay lie forgotten, covered in a thin layer of dust; doctors vaguely splashing their finger tips in the water before touching a patient without gloves and simply using the bed sheet as a substitute. Patients and doctors alike are entrhalled by our tiny hand alcohol gels we whip out every 5 minutes as we have been so religiously taught.

The cots given to anxious parents in Variety Children's Hospital, KCH are a distant twinkling memory as mothers here are all sleeping in the same bed as their feverish/seizing/vomiting children 24 hours a day. At first I thought theer was a deluge of single mothers in Mwanza, before I realised that at 12:00 everyday a steady stream of fathers appear, having been forbidden to enter the ward at any other time except visiting hours. It would seem the burden of childcare in Tanzania still rests firmly with the mothers.
Privacy is a laughable concept, with all the mothers in a bay listening intently to the whole story of each child in the bay as we do rounds. Parents (mothers) barter with one another and swap medications that their child no longer needs as the management plan changes.

So it is in this timewarp, before infection control and sats probe technology that Chris and I undertake our African experience of healthcare.